Doesn't Recommend

fancykitchen5

Joined 3 years ago

Good food, Worst Customer Service. Good food, horrendous customer service.

I recently went to Mike Anderson's for a special occasion with my family and it was ok until the waiter made one mistake and he let it snowball. And then the manager made it inexcusable. They got my father's food order wrong, so they had to go back and make a new dish. The waiter said he would consult with his manager. When he came back to our table he said that my father would get some free lemon pie. I thought it was weird that they did not give him a menu so that he could have a choice in the matter and so I asked the waiter about this. Then he told us that my father was not only getting lemon pie and going to like it, he was going to get one slice of this pie. So of course, my father refused to accept this pathetic excuse for making up for the waiter's mistakes. My father even talked to the manager of the restaurant and the manager himself said that they just usually give their customers lemon pie and that there was "nothing else" that they could do.

Then the waiter rang my father's ticket up incorrectly with an extra item. He fixed that too, but with no apologies.Overall, the food was good but overpriced. The atmosphere is mediocre,"meh" at best even with those aquariums. (Even Chinese buffets have those.)

I have seen far better, superior customer service at many other places that boasted far less in fast food places, Chili's, Joe's Crab Shack, Olive Garden etc. At least if you go to one of those places, they will treat you like a person and go out of their way to help you and make you feel appreciated as a customer. At Mike Anderson's from the lowly waiters up to the manager himself made my family and my father feel that they simply wanted us to pay our money and get out so they could get more customers and make more profit. I simply could not believe the way they treated us as customers, it was appallingly rude and horribly inconsiderate. Mike Anderson's is supposedly according to their website (and fans of the place confirm its boasts), "a Baton Rouge staple," with "fantastic regional food" and "a festive atmosphere". Do you know where else has good food and a "festive atmosphere"? Any decent bar or pub left in the town, which is what Mike Anderson's might as well be, its got the alchohol and the outdoor seating, all they need now is some neon lights and a couple big screen tvs. That way the staff can ignore you half the night whenever they want because they are just a bar and not a Baton Rouge staple or a Louisiana tradition.In sum, I am completely disappointed with this restaurant. If you go there, do not have any expectations of good customer service or a courteous and friendly staff because they simply do not do that anymore. (Especially do not go there for a special occassion with family or friends because not one of the staff there will go out of their way to make you feel welcome or make your special evening feel nice or relaxed or fun.) It is a cheap and hollow and fruitless experience and you might as well go somewhere else for a good time... unless you like atmosphere similar to that of a sports bar, then go to this poor excuse for a once great Louisiana tradition and expect to be ignored for the whole night and not get what you really want. This place is not worth the time or money you would spend to eat there. Go somewhere else.

Doesn't Recommend

Sixlegged

Joined 4 years ago

Avoid the Crawfish. I was unhappy with my dining experience. First, I paid too much for boiled crawfish (1.5 lbs for $15, by contrast they're $3 a pound in the bar down the street). When the waitress brought it out, she spilled hot boiled crawfish juice all over my lap and leg. My pants were soaked and all I got was a weak "I'm sorry, let me get you a napkin." I'm not going back there- it's way overpriced, average quality, and the wait staff isn't customer service oriented.

Doesn't Recommend

lyttlekat

Joined 5 years ago

Poor service and food for holiday dinner with staff. Recently brought my office staff for a christmas dinner. The service was poor and the food was way below average. I will not bring my staff back or recommend anyone to utilize this restaurant for a activity. I was very disappointed.

Doesn't Recommend

monkaree

Joined 6 years ago

Terrible service and OK food...noisy atmosphere. It has been over 4 years since we've been to Mike Anderson's and we plan to never return based on our last visit.

Seating has always taken a long time and wait staff have never been overly-helpful (unless you're someone "important" from LSU like Skip Bertman). Several times we've had to wait while his table was waited on hand and foot. Oh well, that's life, right? The food is good...not great or amazing. It's a bit dark, crowded and noisy but that's ok...if you like that sort of thing.

The last time we visited this mediocre establishment our son was not even 1 yet. We waited for 20 minutes for a seat and finally got a table. The hostess plopped a high-chair on the outside of the table and we put our son in it and began the long wait for our server to arrive....only he/she never did. We waited 20 minutes and the only staff to visit our table came to complain about the placement of the high chair...calling it a fire hazard. We moved it (no one even hinted on helping us find a more suitable location) but were again told, 10 minutes later, that it had to be moved...again with no help at all. After all of that AND no one to even take our drink order after 20 minutes we called the manager over and announced our displeasure. He didn't seem to give a flip and said he'd try to find our waiter. NO THANKS. I can pay less money an other restaurants for MUCH better service and atmosphere AND better food.

If you love it...great. This is just our experience with this restaurant. We've eaten there countless times over the past 10 years and it was never anything amazing but that last trip was the last straw. Besides, if you really like the food you can always buy the cook book and make it yourself without the crappy waitstaff.

Recommends

snedman

Joined 6 years ago

An ok seafood place, at ok prices. Nothing outstanding. I have eaten at two Mike Andersons (Gonzales and BR). I am not sure what everyone raves about. The seafood and other foods were not anything out of the ordinary for this type of restaurant. I guess its a local favorite type of thing. I have spoken to a few of people here, that have lived here for all their lives. They ALL indicate that M.A. has gone down hill in the past several years. They always say "Its not like what it used to be" I have only lived here a few years, but, I hope its not what it used to be, because it was average to me...

Recommends

meangreeneagle

Joined 6 years ago

It's OK. Someone help me because I don't understand why people think Mike Anderson's is that great. Don't get me wrong it wasn't bad but it wasn't outstanding. Nothing we ate made us want to return. It was just ok.

Recommends

emilynf1

Joined 6 years ago

Delicious seafood and lots of it. Mike's is a staple of Baton Rouge seafood. The restaurant is really nice and is always packed in the evenings. Boiled crawfish when it is in season is so well seasoned here. This is also a perfect place for parties - my friend had an engagement party here and it was spacious, there was alot of great food, and the staff was helpful and friendly

Recommends

brdave

Joined 8 years ago

A must for visitors. If you're visiting Baton Rouge, the first place to eat is Mike Anderson's. This is the best seafood in Louisiana. Too many Louisiana seafood restaurants produce generic, fried fish. Not Mike's! A huge variety on the menu, and the stuff that is fried... excellent!

Plan to wait 30-60 minutes on the weekends... the locals all know it's here and it will be crowded.

Recommends

dirty_dan

Joined 8 years ago

South Louisiana at it's best!!!. Long wait to get in and worth every second! I've lived in south Louisiana for 43 years, this is the best seafood restaurant, bar none. If you're looking for French Cusine, go somewhere else. If you're looking for real Louisiana Cajun cooking go here. You won't be sorry.